8 Reasons a Due Diligence Website Audit Protects You

Storyteller Media covers SEO, online business, and marketing. When you use our links, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Purchasing an online business or website can be a lucrative investment, but only if you know exactly what you’re getting. A comprehensive due diligence website audit helps buyers verify the seller’s claims and uncover hidden risks.

Without this step, you could inherit technical issues, revenue inconsistencies, or legal liabilities that could significantly affect the site’s value and profitability.

8 Reasons For a Due Diligence Site Audit (Before Purchasing)

A thorough audit acts as a safety net, helping you make an informed decision and avoid costly mistakes. If you need help, consider our Website Due Diligence Audit for a detailed health check of the site – pre-acquisition.

Here are eight reasons to order a due diligence site audit.

1. Validate Website Performance and Traffic Claims

Website traffic is often a key selling point for online businesses. However, reported numbers can easily be manipulated. A due diligence audit verifies the site’s traffic through direct access to Google Analytics or other analytics platforms.

We’ve seen sites with duplicated analytics tracking codes, which artificially doubled site traffic in the reports. This was done unintentionally, but it presented a very skewed picture of site health nonetheless.

It also examines traffic sources to see if the majority comes from organic search, organic social, referrals, paid ads, or potentially suspicious sources like bots. By reviewing historical traffic patterns, you can confirm whether traffic is stable, growing, or in decline.

1. Confirm reported traffic volume (Google Analytics access, third-party tools)
2. Assess traffic sources (organic, paid, referral)
3. Identify potential traffic manipulation (bots, fake traffic)
4. Verify historical traffic trends

2. SEO Health and Organic Search Potential

A website’s long-term value is connected to its ability to attract relevant organic search traffic. The audit checks for any search engine penalties, either from past violations or current issues.

It also assesses the backlink profile, identifying high-quality links versus spammy or toxic backlinks.

On-page SEO elements like meta tags, internal linking, and content optimization are evaluated to determine whether the site follows best practices. This section helps you understand if the website’s rankings are sustainable or at risk.

1. Check for penalties (manual actions, algorithmic drops)
2. Review backlink profile (quality, spammy links, PBN usage)
3. On-page SEO health (title tags, content quality, internal linking)
4. Indexability and crawlability issues
5. Future ranking potential in the niche

3. Content Quality and Ownership

Content is one of the most valuable site components. The content audit evaluates whether the content is original, high-quality, and up-to-date.

Plagiarism checks confirm if the content has been copied from other sources. Additionally, the audit verifies ownership rights and ensures there are no licensing issues that could expose you to legal risks.

Low-quality, unedited AI-content, and duplicate content could harm the site’s SEO performance and future revenue potential.

1. Originality of content (plagiarism check)
2. Depth, quality, and freshness of content
3. Content ownership rights (licenses, third-party contributions)
4. Thin or duplicate content risks

4. Revenue Verification

Sellers often highlight revenue numbers, but these need independent verification. The audit reviews income sources like Google AdSense, affiliate partnerships, or eCommerce sales.

By comparing revenue claims against transaction records or platform reports, you can confirm the accuracy of reported earnings. It’s also vital to assess revenue consistency, seasonality, and any dependence on a single income stream that could pose a risk if disrupted.

1. Assess revenue claims (Google AdSense, affiliate income, product sales)
2. Check revenue consistency and seasonality
3. Identify reliance on single revenue streams
4. Evaluate third-party monetization contracts (advertisers, partners)

5. Technical Health and Security

A website might appear functional but still have significant technical issues.

The technical audit checks for site speed, mobile-friendliness, indexability, and overall performance. It identifies outdated plugins, CMS versions, or security vulnerabilities that could make the site prone to hacks.

Core Web Vitals assessments provide insights into user experience, which can directly impact search rankings and conversions.

1. Website speed and performance
2. Mobile-friendliness
3. Core Web Vitals
4. SSL certificate and security vulnerabilities
5. Tech stack, plugins, and CMS version (outdated software risks)

6. Legal and Compliance Risks

Online businesses must comply with data privacy laws and copyright regulations. The due diligence audit reviews privacy policies, cookie consent practices, and terms of service to ensure compliance with laws like GDPR or CCPA.

It also checks whether the website uses any third-party images, videos, or content without proper licenses — which could expose the buyer to legal action.

1. GDPR, CCPA, or other privacy regulation compliance
2. Terms of service and privacy policy review
3. Copyright violations
4. Third-party image or content usage without proper licenses

7. Reputation and Brand Equity

A website’s reputation can significantly impact its value.

The audit looks at online reviews, social media presence, and brand mentions across the web. Sentiment analysis helps identify whether the brand has a positive or negative perception.

Domain authority and the quality of backlinks further indicate how well the site is regarded within its niche.

1. Online reviews and sentiment analysis
2. Social media presence and engagement
3. Brand mentions and partnerships
4. Domain authority and backlink reputation

8. Hidden Costs and Migration Risks

Buying a website often comes with additional costs that aren’t always disclosed upfront. The audit identifies any software licenses, hosting contracts, or third-party service subscriptions that must be renewed.

It also evaluates how easy or difficult it will be to transfer ownership of critical accounts like domain registration, hosting, and payment platforms. Understanding these factors can help avoid unexpected expenses and delays.

1. Pending software license renewals
2. Hosting contracts and provider relationships
3. Third-party integrations or API dependencies
4. Difficulty in transferring site ownership or accounts

Need help? Consider our Website Due Diligence Audit for a detailed, pre-acquisition health check of the site.

A due diligence website audit is a crucial step in the acquisition process for many reasons. It goes beyond surface-level metrics to uncover potential risks and validate the site’s true value.

By hiring an independent third-party website expert, buyers can gain a clear picture of the website’s performance, revenue potential, and long-term sustainability. Investing in a comprehensive audit protects your investment and provides the confidence needed to move forward with the purchase.

If you’re considering purchasing a website or online business, request a due diligence audit to ensure you’re making an informed decision.